CigarWeekly - Magazine & forums - Cigar Reviews

Montecristo Linea 1935 Leyenda

smbauerllc@gmail.com (Sean Bauer) — Wed, 12 Apr 2023 15:36:17 -0400

Cigar:

Montecristo Linea 1935 Leyenda

Specifications:

Purchase date: 2019

Country of Origin: Cuba

Wrapper Color: Natural Carmelite

Wrapper type: Cuba

Filler: Cuba

Binder: Cuba

Vitola: Double Robusto (6.5x55)

Manufacturer: Montecristo

Distributor: Habanos S.A.

Factory: H. Upmann Havana, Cuba

Humidimeter: 65%

Current Production: Yes

Price: $77.50 (current)

Environment:

Temperature: 40 degrees

Humidity: 35%

Wind: N/A

Setting:

My regular spot in the little, outdoor smoke shack.

Paired with:

Iced coffee

Rocky Patel Cuban Blend Fumas Toro Maduro

smbauerllc@gmail.com (Sean Bauer) — Thu, 06 Apr 2023 18:06:26 -0400

Cigar

Rocky Patel Cuban Blend Fumas Toro Maduro

Specifications:

Purchase date: 2022

Country of Origin: Nicaragua

Wrapper Color: Maduro

Wrapper type: Maduro

Filler: Honduran Ligero

Binder: Undisclosed

Vitola: Toro (6x52)

Manufacturer: Indian Tabac Cigar Co.

Distributor: Famous Smoke Shop

Factory: Danali, Honduras

Humidimeter: 64%

Current Production: Yes

Price: $3.20

Environment:

Temperature: 20 degrees

Humidity: 73%

Wind: N/A

Setting:

My regular spot in the little, outdoor smoke shack with the gorgeous view of the Big Horn mountain range just a few miles away.

Paired with:

Iced coffee

CAO Flathead Steel Horse Apehanger

smbauerllc@gmail.com (Sean Bauer) — Thu, 06 Apr 2023 17:08:22 -0400

Cigar:

CAO Flathead Steel Horse Apehanger

Specifications:

Manufacture/Purchase date: 2023

Country of Origin: Nicaragua

Wrapper Color: Oscuro

Wrapper type: Connecticut Habano Oscuro

Filler: Dominican Republic, Mexico, Honduras, Nicaragua

Binder: Brazil

Vitola: Grande (5.5x58)

Manufacturer: STG Estelli

Distributor: STG Estelli

Factory: Nicaragua

Humidimeter: 69%

Current Production: Yes

Price: $9.99 (cigars.com single)

Environment:

Temperature: 19 degrees

Humidity: 49%

Wind: N/A

REVIEW: Muestra de Saka Unstolen Valor

jefslat@msn.com (jeffslat) — Tue, 20 Apr 2021 15:54:44 -0400

This cigar has a somewhat veiny medium dark wrapper. The aromas from the foot are very light. The cold draw is perfect. Tonight’s beverage is a (512) Brewing Pecan Porter.

The initial flavor is rich earthy tobacco. The retohale is very smooth with a light touch of white pepper. The ash is firm and the burn is perfect.

In the first third the flavor profile remains earthy tobacco with a somewhat dry finish. The retohale remains unchanged. The ash is light grey and solid. The burn remains perfect. Not being a fan of ash in my lap, I tapped off a very solid chunk at about one inch.

During the second third a touch of sweetness joins the flavor profile, although it may be from the pecan in the ale. The earthy quality of the flavor profile remains strongest. The retohale remains smooth and very lightly peppery. The ash remains solid and the burn remains perfect.

Approaching the final inch the flavor profile remains basically the same. Not one-dimensional though. Very rich and flavorful. Definitely medium bodied. The ash and burn remain excellent. This is a very well constructed cigar with nice complexity.

9.8/10, Joe Bob says check it out.

REVIEW: Asylum 13 Oblongata by CLE

jason@Clabaugh.org (TommyBB) — Fri, 12 Jun 2020 18:21:11 -0400

I never thought that I would be a cigar a day smoker. I was a once-or-twice-a-week guy, not wanting to be absent from my family whilst sitting outside for two hours or so per night. Family situations change, elders need caregivers, caregivers need to get out of the house from the elders and voilá, smoking more than one cigar per day sometimes is suddenly a reality.

My good friend of nearly twenty years at Cigar Weekly sent me a bag of cigars some months back with a request that I let him know about one of them. So, Stan, this is for you, me brother. This is the Asylum 13 Oblongata made by the CLE Cigar Company, founded by Christian L. Eiroa. According to their website, this cigar, called the 60 x 6 due to its dimensions, is made of all corojo tobacco. This should be an experience no matter how it turns out. The Eiroa/CLE corojo farm is in Honduras, according to Cigar Aficionado’s Gregory Mottola, the plantation in the Jamastran Valley once known as Argelia is now called El Corojo after its namesake tobacco. (Gregory Mottola. Crop Report: El Corojo Farm, Honduras. https://www.clecigars.com/crop-report-el-corojo-farm-honduras/ February 5, 2020, accessed May 27, 2020.)

The wrapper leaf is beautiful, simply no other way to describe it, whilst the entire cigar is box-pressed. I almost ruined it clipping it with a tough guillotine cutter. However, I was able to ameliorate the damage. It lights quite nicely with one match and I was met with a strong woody character that coated the back of my tongue. A little ways in and that almost “over-flavor” due to the heat of the lighting has abated a great deal. This is now a pleasant woody cigar, with a nice tight, straight burn.

JNV Maduro Torpedo

pegndoug@sympatico.ca (Michael D’Agostino (Stogiemike)) — Mon, 04 Jun 2018 04:00:03 -0400

June 4th, 2018

Vitola: Torpedo
MSRP: Around $5
Wrapper: San Andrés
Binder: Dominican and Nicaraguan
Filler: Dominican and Nicaraguan

I am truly grateful to be able to review this cigar, which I had heard about from a close friend of mine. I was even able to meet the owner, blender and roller of JNV cigars, Jorge Nicolls (Don Jorge). Not only is he a great cigar brand owner, but also a great man in general. We instantly became friends. Now, onto the review!

Case Study CS/05 ‘Robusto Extra’

pegndoug@sympatico.ca (Brice Sikes (Candid Cigar)) — Thu, 24 May 2018 04:00:03 -0400

May 24th, 2018

This, my final review of the Case Study series from Ventura Cigar Company, is a write-up on the CS/05, one of 26 different blends in the line that pay homage to 26 famous homes built in Los Angeles. The LA homes are renowned for their simplistic, modernist designs and their famous master architects. The Case Study cigars mirror the homes with their simple, minimalist labeling and the fact that all were blended by famous, albeit secret, blend masters.

Sixteen of the blends are ‘Master Editions’, while ten are ‘Limited Editions’. The CS/05 is a limited edition. My knowledge of the cigar is restricted to what venturacigar.com informs me. No information is given regarding the blender’s identity or where the cigar was blended.

The Case Study CS/05 blend comes in three vitolas, respectively measuring 5.75 x 60, 5.75 x 54 and 6.75 x 52. This review profiles what I’ll call the ‘Robusto Extra’, given that its 5.75 x 54 format doesn’t fit conveniently into any established size category. Maybe it’s a short Toro or a fat Double Corona. Who knows? Full disclosure... I love the size of this cigar. At any rate, here’s what I thought of it.

Blanco Liga Exclusiva de Familia Maduro Churchill

pegndoug@sympatico.ca (Jeff Slatton (jefslat)) — Mon, 30 Apr 2018 04:00:03 -0400

April 30th, 2018

It’s an absolutely perfect morning for a cigar and a coffee. This cigar has a dark and somewhat rustic wrapper. The aromas from the foot are earthy and cocoa-like, while the cold draw is perfect. My accompanying morning beverage is a Chameleon Cold Brew.

The initial flavors are peppery and meaty, and there’s lots of smooth smoke to add to the pleasure. The solid ash is a medium grey in tone, and the burn is even except for one place where I’ve scorched the wrapper when lighting the cigar.

Hiram & Solomon Triple Review

pegndoug@sympatico.ca (Jeff Slatton (jefslat)) — Mon, 16 Apr 2018 04:00:03 -0400

April 16th, 2018

In this triple review, Cigar Weekly’s Jeff Slatton (jefslat) ‘test-rides’ the Entered Apprentice Toro, Fellow Craft Toro and Master Mason Robusto, all from the Hiram & Solomon line.

******************************************************

Hiram & Solomon cigars are produced by David Blanco. The lineup features three cigars named for the three Blue Lodge Ranks.

GTO Bueno

pegndoug@sympatico.ca (Chad (The Hangman) Potier) — Thu, 12 Apr 2018 04:00:03 -0400

April 12th, 2018

After three years as producer of The Smooth Draws Radio Show, and with a lot of encouragement from Cigar Weekly’s Big John, I am writing my first cigar review. If you are expecting to read about notes of white pepper, orange peel and saffron, you are in the wrong place. I am an everyday guy who enjoys cigars. So here is my review...

Balmoral Anejo XO Rothschild Masivo

pegndoug@sympatico.ca (Michael D'Agostino (Stogiemike)) — Mon, 09 Apr 2018 04:00:03 -0400

April 9th, 2018

Vitola: Robusto Gordo
MSRP: $9.90
Wrapper: Brazilian Sun Grown Araprica
Binder: Dominican Republic Olor
Filler: Brazilian, Dominican & Nicaraguan

La Palina Nicaragua Toro

pegndoug@sympatico.ca (Jeff Slatton (jefslat)) — Mon, 26 Mar 2018 04:00:03 -0400

March 26th, 2018

In this 'back-to-back' review, Cigar Weekly's Special Correspondent, Jeff Slatton, profiles the Oscuro and Connecticut wrapper versions of the La Palina Nicaragua Toro.

The La Palina Nicaragua lineup is rolled at the A.J. Fernandez factory (Tabacalera Fernandez), giving me fairly high expectations of quality construction. Both the Oscuro and Connecticut reviewed here are Toros.

* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *

Steve Saka Muestra de Saka Nacatamale

pegndoug@sympatico.ca (Jeff Slatton (jefslat)) — Mon, 05 Mar 2018 05:00:03 -0500

March 5th, 2018

My sample sports a perfectly smooth dark wrapper. There’s a light tobacco sweetness coming from the wrapper and foot, with traces of Ligero also present. An ideal draw leads me to believe that this will be a great cigar. Today’s beverage is an Avery Brewing Tweak, a 16% beer that provides a kick all of its own.

The perfect draw affords a purely tasty mouth-feel. The retro-hale has just the right amount of pepper to balance out the flavor. There is also a nice touch of pepper on the palate.

The Wise Man Maduro Corona Gorda

pegndoug@sympatico.ca (Aaron Handelman (H311oLHD)) — Mon, 05 Feb 2018 05:00:03 -0500

February 5th, 2018

Size of cigar: 5 5/8 inches by 46-ring gauge
Wrapper: San Andrés Mexican Maduro
Binder: Nicaraguan Corojo ‘99
Fillers: Nicaraguan

The Wise Man Maduro represents a follow up to Foundation Cigar Company’s wildly popular El Güegüense. The cigar features the same artwork on the label as the El Güegüense. However, the blue label of the latter has been replaced with a red backdrop. The Wise Man debuted during the 2017 IPCPR, and hit stores several months later in September.

CW's Best New Cigars of 2017

jason@Clabaugh.org (Jason Clabaugh (BigO)) — Mon, 29 Jan 2018 05:00:03 -0500

January 29th, 2018

Publisher's Note: This is Part One of a two-part series. The Top 10 Cigars of 2017 will be published as the next installment.

Below is a listing of Cigar Weekly's best new cigars of 2017. These results were obtained by conducting a poll of the entire membership of Cigar Weekly. In addition, the CW Review Crew has added their comments about these cigars in the Cigar Reviews forum. The cigars are presented in order, followed by comments drawn from the reviews.

#1. Dunbarton Tobacco & Trust - Todo Las Dias

"The burn is perfect... a very smooth yet strong cigar." "It also smokes very slow, adding to the flavor." "The wrapper and foot smell like coffee with a light touch of leather." "Very light white pepper." "Comparing the cigar with Saka's other offerings, it's more like the Sobramesa than the Mi Querida, but is its own cigar."

"Medium-bodied smoke and flavors of coffee and leather."

"At 2/3, it changes again to a very pleasant flavor almost beyond description." "To say it completely changes is a very good description." "At 2/3, the strength has built to full-bodied"

"Nearing the end of the cigar provides yet another flavor change that is again representative of a pleasant complexity."

"The cigar starts off medium-bodied and builds to full."

"I don't want it to end."

Case Study CS/04 Torpedo

pegndoug@sympatico.ca (Brice Sikes (Candid Cigar)) — Mon, 18 Dec 2017 05:00:03 -0500

December 18th, 2017

Size of cigar: 5.5 inches by 52 ring gauge

The Case Study line comes from Ventura Cigar Company. In reality, there are 26 Case Study blends. Each blend is available in one to four vitolas. The 26 blends pay homage to 26 famous homes built in the simplistic, modernist architectural design and located in Los Angeles – hence the simple labeling.

Black Label Trading Company Last Rites Petite Lancero

pegndoug@sympatico.ca (Jeff Slatton (jefslat)) — Mon, 04 Dec 2017 05:00:03 -0500

December 4th, 2017

Size of cigar: 6.5 inches by 42 ring gauge

This cigar has a very nice, smooth Maduro wrapper. The bunch is firm with no soft spots, and the wrapper gives off an aroma of cocoa nibs and leather along with some spices. The cold draw is perfect. My chosen accompanying beverage is a Southern Star Winter Warmer Ale.

The initial draws off the cigar are full bodied with plentiful smoke. There are leather and spice notes. The construction looks very good, with a clean burn and a layered medium grey ash evident. The ale provides a good pairing, with tastes that enhance the flavors of the cigar.